Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet Menu With Prices
If you know New Jersey deli culture, you know Taliercio’s. Tucked along Route 35 in the Red Bank–Middletown area, Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet has spent decades building a near-cult following on the back of towering, over-the-top sandwiches, a display case overflowing with prepared Italian specialties, and a family-owned warmth that regulars describe as walking into your Italian grandparents’ kitchen. It’s the kind of place people drive an hour for — and one with a sandwich named after seemingly every entertainer, ballplayer, and mob-movie character you can think of.
This is the complete Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet menu guide for 2026, with prices across every category: the famous heroes, hot paninis, gourmet grilled cheeses, catering trays, prepared salads, fried specialties, and more. Whether you’re planning your first visit, building a catering order, or just trying to figure out what to get from that legendary hanging chalkboard of sandwiches, this guide lays it all out.
A quick, honest note up front: Taliercio’s is an independent, family-run deli (not a chain), and prices on the in-store chalkboard, the deli case, and the party-hero/catering side can differ from the online ordering menu. The prices below come from Taliercio’s current online ordering menu as a reliable reference; we’ve flagged what to confirm directly.

About Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet
Taliercio’s has been family-owned since 1988, and that heritage is the whole personality of the place. It operates as a gourmet Italian deli along Route 35 in the Red Bank / Middletown, NJ area of Monmouth County, with a reputation that long ago outgrew its zip code.
A few things make it special:
- The sandwiches are an event. Dozens of signature heroes and paninis line the chalkboards, each with a creative name and a loaded build. Regulars warn newcomers: these are big — one sandwich can easily feed a hungry adult.
- The deli case is a destination. Beyond sandwiches, the cases overflow with prepared Italian foods — fried eggplant, rice balls, broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella and burrata, chicken cutlets, pastas, and more — plus hand-trimmed, high-quality meats and cold cuts by the pound.
- It ships nationwide. Through Goldbelly, Taliercio’s sends its specialties across the country, so the experience isn’t limited to people who can get to New Jersey.
- Catering is a core business. From holiday trays (order early for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter) to their famous 3-foot and 6-foot Party Heroes, Taliercio’s caters corporate events, family gatherings, and sports parties year-round.
- There’s a face to it. Owner Eric Taliercio and the team have built a massive social-media following, and the in-store personality — the encouragement to build your own creation and name it — is a big part of the draw.
In short: it’s an old-school Italian deli “on steroids,” as more than one reviewer has put it.
Taliercio’s Heroes Menu With Prices
The heroes are the headliners. There are 70+ named sandwiches on the menu, the overwhelming majority priced at a flat $23.95 — and they’re sized to match, generously loaded with quality meats, imported cheeses, and house-made touches. Below is a representative selection of the lineup; the full board is even longer.
| Hero | Build | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Italian Hero | Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar | $23.95 |
| New Yorker | Imported prosciutto, salami, mortadella, provolone, roasted peppers | $23.95 |
| The Gobbler | Boar’s Head turkey, homemade stuffing, jellied cranberry, mayo | $23.95 |
| Big Mike | Ham, capicola, sweet soppressata, provolone, fresh mozzarella, balsamic | $23.95 |
| Peter Lugar | Hot roast beef, fresh mozzarella & Peter Luger sauce | $23.95 |
| John J | Chicken cutlet, prosciutto, artichoke hearts, hot peppers, burrata & pesto | $23.95 |
| Luca Brasi | Chicken cutlet, long hot peppers, burrata & vodka sauce | $23.95 |
| Peaky Blinder | Hot roast beef, cheddar, mashed potatoes & brown gravy | $23.95 |
| El Chapo | Chipotle chicken, 3-pepper Colby, con queso, bacon & nacho chips | $23.95 |
| The Paddy | Pastrami, corned beef, turkey pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut & mustard | $23.95 |
| Cobra Kai | Teriyaki chicken, black forest ham, smoked gouda, banana peppers, sesame-ginger | $23.95 |
| Heavyweight | Turkey, roast beef, chicken cutlet, pepper jack, hot peppers & BBQ | $23.95 |
| Apollo Creed | Veal cutlet, ham, fresh mozzarella, spinach & marsala sauce | $23.95 |
| The Dinapoli | Fried veal cutlet, fresh mozzarella, tomato bruschetta & balsamic | $23.95 |
| Klocko | Chicken cutlet, broccoli rabe, fried eggplant, sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, balsamic | $23.95 |
| Cast Away | Fried flounder, coleslaw, baby arugula, roasted peppers, oil & lemon | $23.95 |
| Black Russian | Roast beef, lettuce, tomato, red onion & horseradish pub sauce on pumpernickel | $23.95 |
| Tony Montana | Roast beef, blue cheese crumbles, arugula, hot cherry peppers & horseradish pub sauce | $23.95 |
| The Gambino | Veal cutlet, baby arugula, tomato bruschetta & fresh lemon | $23.95 |
| Imported Prosciutto | Imported prosciutto, fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers | $23.95 |
| Doo-Wop | Homemade roast beef, fresh mozzarella, broccoli rabe & balsamic glaze | $23.95 |
| The Healthy Choice | Honey maple turkey, Alpine Swiss, cucumber, red onion & red vinegar | $23.95 |
| Chicken Parmigiana | Breaded chicken, tomato sauce, mozzarella | $23.95 |
| Meatball Parmigiana | Meatballs, red sauce, mozzarella & romano | $23.95 |
| Reuben | Hot corned beef, Swiss, coleslaw & Russian dressing | $23.95 |
The full board runs 70+ heroes — including the E-Tali, Nonna Murphy, Mikey A, Cannonball, Breadman, Ronnie Special, JPV, Siciliano, Chalky White, Testa’s Muffaletta, and many more. Nearly all are $23.95. And per local lore: if you build your own and the staff names it, they’ll remember it next time. [VERIFY current hero pricing — board prices may differ from online]

Taliercio’s Hot Paninis With Prices
The pressed hot paninis are named after entertainers and screen legends, and most run $15.95 (a couple are $17.95).
| Panini | Build | Price |
|---|---|---|
| The Godfather | Prosciutto di Parma, fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomato & basil pesto | $15.95 |
| The Sinatra | Boar’s Head turkey, Swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato & dijonnaise | $15.95 |
| The Al Pacino | Ever-roast chicken, Colby jack, bacon & ranch | $15.95 |
| The Mel Brooks | Corned beef & pastrami, Swiss, coleslaw & Russian dressing | $15.95 |
| The Dean Martin | Homemade roast beef, American, red onion & horseradish pub sauce | $15.95 |
| Tony Soprano | Imported ham, Genoa salami, provolone, red onion & red wine vinegar | $15.95 |
| Carmela Soprano | Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella & marinated sun-dried tomatoes | $15.95 |
| The Jersey Shore | Fried chicken cutlet, cheddar, hot peppers, tomato & ranch | $15.95 |
| Sammy Davis, Jr. | Turkey pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss & Russian dressing | $15.95 |
| The Marilyn Monroe | Sautéed vegetables, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic | $15.95 |
| Fredo | Shredded chicken cutlet, imported ham, Swiss & honey mustard | $17.95 |
| Danny Boy | Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, hot cherry peppers & ranch | $17.95 |
Other paninis on the board include the Donnie Brasco, Jack Nicholson, The Capolino, Louie Prima, The Blazin’ Saddle, Chevy Chase, Cheech & Chong, John Candy, The All American BBQ, The John Wayne, The Hammer, Ricky Ricardo, and The Deniro — most at $15.95.
Taliercio’s Gourmet Grilled Cheeses
These aren’t your childhood grilled cheese — they’re loaded, named after U.S. cities and states, and range $12.95–$16.95.
| Grilled Cheese | Build | Price |
|---|---|---|
| The Philly | American, mozzarella, roast beef, peppers & onions | $16.95 |
| The Memphis BBQ | Cheddar, pepper jack, BBQ chicken cutlet, BBQ sauce & pickle | $16.95 |
| Nashville Hot Chicken | Buffalo chicken, pepper jack, cheddar, pickles & hot sauce | $16.95 |
| The Dirty South | Mac & cheese with pulled pork | $14.95 |
| The Windy City | Salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, provolone & marinara | $12.95 |
| The Golden State | Swiss, low-fat mozzarella, turkey, avocado & tomato | $12.95 |
| The Big Wisconsin | American, cheddar, bacon & tomato | $12.95 |
| The Big Apple | Corned beef, pastrami, Swiss & sauerkraut | $12.95 |
| The Bean Town | Roast beef, cheddar, mozzarella & Russian dressing | $12.95 |

Catering Trays (Serve 8–10 People)
Catering is a Taliercio’s signature. These are half trays that feed 8–10 people, delivered cold and ready to heat, priced $61.00–$65.99.
| Tray | Price |
|---|---|
| Chicken Taliercio (best seller — rolled Cordon Bleu style with the world-famous Taliercio sauce & tomato bruschetta) | $65.99 |
| Chicken Parm (breaded cutlets, mozzarella, parm, marinara) | $65.99 |
| Chicken Francaise (battered chicken in lemon sauce) | $65.99 |
| Baked Ziti | $61.00 |
| Penne alla Vodka | $61.00 |
| Cheese Lasagna | $61.00 |
| Eggplant Parm | $61.00 |
| Eggplant Rollatini (12 pc, ricotta & parm, marinara, mozzarella) | $61.00 |
| Cavatelli & Broccoli | $61.00 |
| Meatballs (“award-winning” beef meatballs in marinara) | $61.00 |
| Rolled Roast Beef & Gravy (12 pc top round with house mashed potatoes & brown gravy) | $61.00 |
Party Heroes: Taliercio’s also makes its famous 3-foot and 6-foot Party Heroes — the “kings of all deli platters” — built with the finest meats and cheeses for groups. These are priced separately and not on the standard online menu. [VERIFY party hero pricing — call to order]
Specialties & Fried Favorites
The fried specialties are a huge part of the appeal — and the Fried Ravioli is the signature best seller people rave about.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Buffalo Wings | $14.95 |
| Fried Shrimp (with cocktail sauce) | $14.95 |
| Mac & Cheese Bites | $12.95 |
| Chicken Tenders | $10.99 |
| Prosciutto Balls | $10.99 |
| Fried Ravioli (best seller) | $9.99 |
| Fried Zucchini | $9.99 |
| Mozzarella Sticks (with marinara) | $8.95 |
| French Fries | $8.95 |
| Sweet Potato Fries | $8.95 |
| Riceballs | $4.99 |
| Potato Croquette | $3.99 |
| Pizza Bagels | $2.99 |
Strombolis — $13.95 each
Meatball Parmigiana · Eggplant Parmigiana · Chicken Parmigiana · Sausage, Peppers & Onions Parmigiana
Eggrolls — $6.95 each
Buffalo Chicken · Pulled Pork · Chicken Parmigiana · Reuben · Philly Cheesesteak

Pizza & Focaccia
Taliercio’s also offers focaccia-style pizzas — including a fan-favorite topped with their fried ravioli.
| Pizza | Price |
|---|---|
| Ravioli Pizza (fried ravioli focaccia) | $45.00 |
| Buffalo Style Pizza | $39.95 |
| Stuffed Pizza with Ricotta | $39.95 |
| Margherita with Cherry Tomato | $34.95 |
| Plain Focaccia Pizza | $29.95 |
Prepared Salads & Sides
The deli case is loaded with house-made salads sold by the container — perfect alongside a hero or for a spread at home.
| Salad | Price |
|---|---|
| Marinated Sundried Tomatoes | $12.99 |
| Mixed Olive Salad | $12.99 |
| Chicken Salad (best seller) | $12.99 |
| Tuna Salad | $12.99 |
| Marinated Mozzarella Balls | $12.99 |
| Eggplant Caponata | $12.99 |
| Antipasto Salad | $12.99 |
| Marinated Mushroom | $10.99 |
| Marinated Artichoke | $10.99 |
| Tomato Bruschetta | $10.99 |
| Red Roasted Peppers | $10.99 |
| Tortellini Salad | $10.99 |
| Rotini Pasta Salad | $9.99 |
| Greek Pasta Salad | $9.99 |
| Redskin Potato Salad (best seller) | $8.99 |
| Tri-Spud Potato Salad | $8.99 |
| German Potato Salad | $8.99 |
| Egg Salad | $8.99 |
| Coleslaw (best seller) | $5.99 |
| Macaroni Salad | $5.99 |
| Potato Salad | $5.99 |
Entrée Specialty Salads
- Classic Chicken Caesar — $17.95
- Cobb Salad — $17.95
- Italian Salad — $14.95
Desserts & Drinks
- Assorted Italian Cookies — $10.99
- Soda — $2.99 · Snapple — $2.50 · Poland Spring Water — $1.99
A Note on Pricing
Taliercio’s is an independent, family-owned deli, so a few things affect pricing:
- The prices above come from Taliercio’s online ordering menu and are a reliable reference, but in-store chalkboard prices, deli-case items, and cold cuts by the pound may differ.
- Party Heroes (3 ft / 6 ft), full catering spreads, and Goldbelly nationwide shipping are priced separately — call or check the relevant site to order.
- Holiday trays (Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter) sell out and require ordering well in advance.
Always confirm current pricing and availability directly with Taliercio’s before placing a large or catering order.

What to Order: Standout Picks
First time at Taliercio’s? Here’s where to start.
The Fried Ravioli. The signature best seller for a reason — savory filling in a crispy, golden fried pasta shell. At $9.99, it’s the table starter you don’t skip.
Chicken Taliercio. The best-selling catering item and the dish that shows off the kitchen — chicken rolled Cordon Bleu style, stuffed with the “world-famous” Taliercio sauce and finished with fresh tomato bruschetta. Worth building a meal (or a party) around.
A signature hero. Pick a name that speaks to you — the prosciutto-and-burrata John J, the roast-beef-and-mashed-potato Peaky Blinder, or the classic loaded Italian Hero. They’re all $23.95 and all enormous. Reviewers consistently note one sandwich can feed a big appetite.
The deli case. Don’t leave without grabbing prepared sides — the chicken salad, redskin potato salad, eggplant caponata, or marinated mozzarella balls are all case favorites.
A Party Hero for a crowd. Hosting? The 3-foot or 6-foot Party Hero is the move — Taliercio’s calls them the kings of all deli platters, and they’re built for value and crowd appeal.
Quick-Glance: Best Picks
| If you want… | Order this | Price |
|---|---|---|
| The signature starter | Fried Ravioli | $9.99 |
| The must-try entrée | Chicken Taliercio (tray) | $65.99 |
| The classic sandwich | Italian Hero | $23.95 |
| A creative loaded hero | John J or Luca Brasi | $23.95 |
| A pressed favorite | The Godfather Panini | $15.95 |
| Feeding a crowd | 3 ft / 6 ft Party Hero | Call to order |
Hours, Locations & Ordering
Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet is located along Route 35 in the Red Bank / Middletown, NJ area (the business markets both — the stretch of Highway 35 sits near the Red Bank–Middletown line). The main contact number is (732) 576-1888.
Address & hours note: Listings show the deli at 544 Highway 35 (Middletown 07701) and online ordering at 500 NJ-35, Red Bank 07701 — confirm the exact location you want before heading over. Hours have historically run roughly 9:00 AM–6:00 PM on weekdays with shorter Sunday hours, but these change, so verify current hours and address before visiting. [VERIFY hours & exact location]
Ways to order:
- In-store — the full chalkboard, deli case, and build-your-own experience.
- Online ordering / delivery & pickup — via the deli’s online menu (Slice) for sandwiches, specialties, and trays.
- Catering — call ahead for trays, Party Heroes, and holiday orders (order early for major holidays).
- Nationwide shipping — through Goldbelly, which ships Taliercio’s specialties across the U.S.
Searching for a Taliercio’s menu PDF? The most current and accurate menu is whatever’s live on the deli’s online ordering page, since chalkboard offerings rotate and prices update. The deli’s own website also posts catering and special-event menus.
Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet FAQ
What is Taliercio’s known for?
Taliercio’s is known for its over-the-top signature heroes (70+ creatively named sandwiches), its best-selling Fried Ravioli, Chicken Taliercio, an overflowing case of prepared Italian foods, and its famous 3-foot and 6-foot Party Heroes for catering. It’s a beloved family-owned NJ Italian deli.
Where is Taliercio’s located?
Along Route 35 in the Red Bank / Middletown, NJ area of Monmouth County. Confirm the exact address and hours before visiting, as listings vary between 500 and 544 Highway 35.
How much is a sandwich at Taliercio’s?
Most signature heroes are $23.95 and are very large. Hot paninis run about $15.95–$17.95, and gourmet grilled cheeses are $12.95–$16.95. (Confirm current pricing in-store.)
Does Taliercio’s cater?
Yes — it’s a core part of the business. Catering trays serve 8–10 people and run $61–$65.99, and they make 3-foot and 6-foot Party Heroes. They also do holiday and special-event menus; order early for major holidays.
Does Taliercio’s ship nationwide?
Yes — Taliercio’s ships its specialties across the country through Goldbelly.
How big are the sandwiches?
Big. Regulars consistently note that a single hero can fill up even a large appetite — these are loaded, substantial sandwiches.
Is Taliercio’s a chain?
No. It’s an independent, family-owned gourmet deli, in business since 1988.
Does Taliercio’s have vegetarian options?
Yes — options like the Eggplant Parmigiana hero, the Marilyn Monroe veggie panini, Taliercio’s Garden hero, fried zucchini, and numerous prepared veggie salads. Confirm specific ingredients in-store.
Final Thoughts
Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet is the rare deli that lives up to its own legend. The heroes are huge and inventive, the prepared-food case is a genuine destination, the catering is built for a crowd, and the family-owned hospitality is the real signature ingredient. Start with the Fried Ravioli, pick a hero whose name makes you smile, and grab a few things from the case on your way out — and if you’re hosting, the Party Heroes and catering trays are hard to beat.