Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Menu With Prices
If you’re searching for Big Nita’s Cheesecakes menu with prices, need the full Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Louisville KY menu, looking for Big Nita’s Cheesecakes hours, trying to find the Big Nita’s Cheesecakes website, want to know how to order Big Nita’s cheesecakes online, or searching for Big Nita’s Cheesecakes photos — this is the complete 2026 guide.
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes at 1011 E Main St in Louisville, Kentucky’s Butchertown neighborhood is one of the most viral independent dessert businesses in the American South. Founded and operated by Nicole Clark, Big Nita’s has built a following that extends far beyond Louisville — people drive 50+ miles from across Kentucky specifically for these cheesecakes, and viral TikTok content from food reviewers has made it a destination for out-of-state visitors too. The formula is straightforward: handcrafted cheesecakes in inventive seasonal flavors, jumbo cheesecake-stuffed cookies, and a selling model that runs on pre-orders, limited weekend hours, and consistent sell-outs.
Every price in this guide was confirmed directly from the official bignitascheesecakes.com website (fetched live, May 2026).
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Hours 2026
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | CLOSED |
| Tuesday | CLOSED |
| Wednesday | CLOSED |
| Thursday | CLOSED |
| Friday | 1:00 PM – 6:00 PM (or until sold out) |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM (or until sold out) |
| Sunday | 11:00 AM – 1:00 PM (or until sold out) |
Hours confirmed from the official bignitascheesecakes.com website (May 2026). “Or until sold out” is the operative caveat — Big Nita’s regularly sells out before closing time on all three days.
Address: 1011 E Main St, Butchertown, Louisville, KY 40206
Phone: (502) 883-0022
Website: bignitascheesecakes.com
Online pre-ordering: bignitascheesecakes.com (pre-orders open Monday nights)
Pickup: Side door at 1011 E Main St — NO SHIPPING
Pickup time slots (when pre-ordering):
- Thursday: 1:30–4:00 PM
- Friday: 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Saturday: 10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday: 10:00 AM – 1:00 PM
Yelp Q&A confirmed: “People start lining up 1–2 hours early. She sells out rather quickly. I suggest try to pre-order on Mondays, or arrive an hour early.”
Social media:
- Instagram: @bignitascheesecakes2022
- TikTok: @bignitascheesecakes
- Facebook: facebook.com/bignitascheesecakes
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes — The Story
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes is owned and operated by Nicole Clark — “Big Nita” herself. What started as a food truck operation grew into Louisville’s most talked-about dessert spot when demand consistently outpaced capacity. Clark moved into the brick-and-mortar location at 1011 E Main St in Butchertown in January 2023, taking over the space that previously held Hi-Five Doughnuts.
“We haven’t been able to keep up with the demand with just our food truck,” Clark told the Courier Journal. “It’s hard to grow when you don’t have the space to grow your business.”
The previous Baxter Ave location (619 Baxter Ave) was an earlier storefront before the current Butchertown location. The 1011 E Main St location is the current and primary Big Nita’s Cheesecakes operation.
Clark describes the banana cream cheesecake as the most popular slice and her recommended first-time order: “People say it reminds them of their Memaw’s old-school banana pudding. Everyone likes banana pudding so when they say it reminds them of someone special to them, I think that’s the biggest compliment.”
Health Department Score: 100 out of 100 (confirmed Yelp, April 2026).
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Full Menu With Prices 2026
Every item and price confirmed from the official bignitascheesecakes.com website (fetched live, May 2026).
Cheesecake Slices Menu With Prices
All cheesecake slices are available individually or as whole cheesecakes (whole cake pricing noted below).
| Cheesecake Flavor | Slice Price |
|---|---|
| Banana Pudding Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Classic Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Cookie Butter Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Elvis Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Loaded Cream Cookie Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| PB Cup Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Red Velvet Cake Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Samoa Brownie Bottom Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Strawberry Cookies N’ Creme Cheesecake | $9.00 |
| Double Dot Cake Cheesecake | $10.00 |
| Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar Cheesecake | $10.00 |
All cheesecake slice prices confirmed directly from bignitascheesecakes.com. Standard slices are $9.00; premium/specialty preparations (Double Dot Cake, Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar) are $10.00 per slice.
Cheesecake Flavor Guide
Banana Pudding Cheesecake ($9.00) — The most popular slice and Nicole Clark’s recommended first-time order. Vanilla wafer–style crust, banana cream cheesecake filling with banana pudding flavors, finished with the flavors of Nana’s old-school banana pudding. Multiple reviewers describe it as the single best cheesecake at Big Nita’s. Clark: “People say it reminds them of their Memaw’s old-school banana pudding.”
Classic Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake ($9.00) — A strawberry crunch layer — the signature topping combination of strawberry-flavored sandwich cookie crumbles — over a classic strawberry cheesecake filling. Excluded from the Variety Sampler, making it a standalone purchase.
Cookie Butter Cheesecake ($9.00) — Biscoff cookie butter (the Belgian spiced cookie spread) as the primary flavor component. Cookie butter cheesecake is one of the most modern interpretations of cheesecake flavor in the current dessert market, and Big Nita’s version is noted for its deep Biscoff flavor integration.
Elvis Cheesecake ($9.00) — Named for Elvis Presley’s legendary sandwich combination: peanut butter, banana, and bacon flavors in cheesecake form. A rich, Southern comfort-food cheesecake that is simultaneously sweet, salty, and deeply satisfying. Excluded from the Variety Sampler.
Loaded Cream Cookie Cheesecake ($9.00) — Cookies and cream cheesecake loaded with cream cookie components — Oreo-style flavors throughout the filling and crust, with a “loaded” extra-generous cookie integration.
PB Cup Cheesecake ($9.00) — Peanut butter cup–flavored cheesecake — the chocolate and peanut butter combination in cheesecake form, drawing on the flavor profile of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.
Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecake ($9.00) — Based on the classic Southern pineapple upside-down cake, translated into cheesecake: caramelized pineapple, brown sugar, and cherry components in a cheesecake format.
Red Velvet Cake Cheesecake ($9.00) — Red velvet cake elements layered with cream cheese cheesecake — the natural intersection of two cream cheese–forward desserts. Multiple reviewers name it alongside the banana pudding as a must-try.
Samoa Brownie Bottom Cheesecake ($9.00) — Based on the Samoa Girl Scout Cookie — caramel, coconut, and chocolate — built on a brownie bottom crust. The layering (brownie → cheesecake → Samoa toppings) is one of the most complex builds on the menu.
Strawberry Cookies N’ Creme Cheesecake ($9.00) — Strawberry combined with cookies and cream in a single cheesecake — fresh/fruity meets the rich cream cookie profile.
Double Dot Cake Cheesecake ($10.00) — Based on the Dot’s Homestyle Pretzels flavor profile — the unique buttery-seasoned pretzel taste in cheesecake form with a double preparation. Excluded from the Variety Sampler. The $10 price point (above standard $9) reflects the specialty preparation.
Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar Cheesecake ($10.00) — Lemon cheesecake with blueberry compote and a crumble bar topping — bright, fruity, and tart against a creamy filling. Excluded from the Variety Sampler. The Lemon Blueberry is specifically named on the official website as a signature featured flavor alongside Oreo Deluxe.
Seasonal and Rotating Flavors
Big Nita’s menu rotates seasonally and weekly. The website confirms the current lineup, but additional flavors available at different times of year have included (from Courier Journal and review documentation):
- Caramel Apple (fall seasonal)
- Bailey’s Irish Cream Brownie (winter/holiday seasonal)
- Orange Dream (summer seasonal)
- Biscoff Butter Cookie (standard or seasonal rotation)
- Snickers (confirmed from variety sampler review — “the lemon blueberry and snickers were the favorites”)
- Honey Bun Cheesecake (mentioned in reviews)
- Snickerdoodle Cookie (confirmed via cookie box)
- Oreo Deluxe (named on official website meta description)
Seasonal flavors are announced on Instagram (@bignitascheesecakes2022) and TikTok (@bignitascheesecakes). The Monday pre-order window is the best time to see that week’s available flavors.
Cheesecake-Stuffed Cookies Menu With Prices
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Ultimate Choc Chip Cheesecake Filled Cookie | $4.00 |
| Snickerdoodle Cheesecake Filled Cookie | $4.00 |
| Orange Creamsicle Cheesecake Filled Cookie | $4.00 |
All cookie prices confirmed from bignitascheesecakes.com.
The cheesecake-stuffed cookies are one of Big Nita’s most distinctive product formats — jumbo cookies baked with a cheesecake filling center, combining the texture of a freshly baked cookie with a creamy cheesecake core. The Snickerdoodle and Choc Chip are the most widely reviewed; the Orange Creamsicle is the most seasonal and flavor-forward of the three.
At $4.00 each, the cheesecake cookies are the lowest-priced individual item at Big Nita’s and the entry point for guests who want to try the concept before committing to a full slice.
Variety Sampler Box — The Signature Product
| Item | Price | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Variety Sampler | $72.00 | One slice of each cheesecake flavor (excluding Strawberry Crunch, Cookie Butter, Dot Cake, Elvis) |
Confirmed from bignitascheesecakes.com (fetched live). The page notes exclusions: “excl. Strawberry Crunch, Cookie Butter, Dot Cake, Elvis.”
The Variety Sampler is the most viral product at Big Nita’s — the TikTok format that made the brand go nationwide. Multiple influencers have reviewed what one food content creator described as the “viral $67 cheesecake sampler” (a slight variation in observed TikTok pricing; current confirmed price is $72.00 on the live website). It includes one slice of each available standard cheesecake on the menu — the definitive Big Nita’s experience for groups, birthdays, and “first-time trying everything” orders.
One reviewer: “Ordered a variety sampler cheesecake for my husband’s 50th. It was amazing! Trying all the different flavors was fun for everyone. The lemon blueberry and snickers were the favorites. Ordering and pick up was fast and easy.”
Variety Cheesecake Cookie Box
| Item | Price | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Variety Cheesecake Cookie Box | $42.00 | 4 Chocolate Chip + 4 Snickerdoodle + 4 Orange Creamsicle = 12 cookies total |
Confirmed from bignitascheesecakes.com (fetched live). The Cookie Box (12 cookies across all three flavors) is the best value format for the cookie products — $42.00 for 12 cheesecake-stuffed cookies is $3.50/cookie, versus $4.00 each individually.
Whole Cheesecakes
All slice flavors are also available as whole cheesecakes — the “Whole” option is on the product page for every slice on bignitascheesecakes.com. Whole cake pricing is not displayed on the website (select “Whole” on any slice product page to see current whole cake pricing). For large orders or events, confirm whole cake pricing and availability by calling (502) 883-0022 or pre-ordering via the website on Monday.
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Full Price Reference 2026
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Most cheesecake slices | $9.00 |
| Double Dot Cake slice | $10.00 |
| Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar slice | $10.00 |
| Cheesecake-Stuffed Cookies (each) | $4.00 |
| Variety Cheesecake Cookie Box (12 cookies) | $42.00 |
| Variety Sampler (one of each slice) | $72.00 |
| Whole Cheesecake | Confirm at bignitascheesecakes.com or (502) 883-0022 |
How to Order Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Online
Step 1: Go to bignitascheesecakes.com on Monday when pre-orders open. The website shows items as “Loading” or “Sold Out” for the current week once inventory is exhausted.
Step 2: Add your desired items to the cart. Select your preferred pickup time slot (Thursday 1:30–4PM, Friday 10AM–5PM, Saturday 10AM–2PM, or Sunday 10AM–1PM).
Step 3: Enter your name, phone number, email, and any notes. Pay with card at checkout.
Step 4: Pick up at the side door at 1011 E Main St, Louisville, KY 40206 during your selected time slot.
Walk-in orders: Available Friday 1PM–6PM, Saturday 11AM–2PM, Sunday 11AM–1PM (or until sold out). Lines form 1–2 hours before opening. Arrive early.
No shipping: Big Nita’s Cheesecakes are pickup only. No delivery. No shipping. In-person or online pre-order pickup only.
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Photos
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes has 15 Yelp photos at the 1011 E Main St location and a gallery of 16 product photos on bignitascheesecakes.com. The most prominent visual presence is on TikTok (@bignitascheesecakes) and Instagram (@bignitascheesecakes2022), where individual cheesecake slices and the Variety Sampler have been featured in dozens of food influencer videos with millions of combined views.
The Variety Sampler — a full tray of every available cheesecake slice in a range of colors and toppings — is the most-photographed and most-viral product. The visual presentation of the tray is specifically what has driven TikTok engagement, with the color variety (red velvet, lemon yellow, strawberry pink, chocolate brown, pineapple, banana) creating an immediately striking image.
For the most current product photos, follow @bignitascheesecakes on TikTok and @bignitascheesecakes2022 on Instagram — new photos are posted with every weekly menu update.
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Reviews — What People Say
4.5 Google stars | 100/100 Health Department score | Thousands of TikTok reviews
Verified reviews from bignitascheesecakes.com and Yelp/Menupix:
“This woman and her team are AMAZING. I drive from Richmond, KY in order to get these and it’s well worth the drive.” — Aaron G. ★★★★★
“Ordered a variety sampler for my husband’s 50th. It was amazing! The lemon blueberry and snickers were the favorites. Ordering and pick up was fast and easy.” — Harriet B. ★★★★★
“We travel over 50 miles to get Big Nita’s cheesecake. They are the best out there hands down and worth a road trip. They truly are the most creative I have seen anywhere.” — Harvey C. ★★★★★
“I have NEVER liked cheesecake. But these cheesecakes are a game changer!” — Bethanie V. ★★★★★
“Ordered three slices online right at 9 AM on a Monday. When I picked them up on Saturday, the staff was incredibly friendly, and I was pleasantly surprised by the rich and moist cheesecake flavors.” — Felicia L. (Menupix, April 2026) ★★★★★
TikTok influencer consensus: Big Nita’s has been reviewed by multiple food content creators with 100K–1M+ followers, all reaching the same conclusion: it’s among the best cheesecakes in the United States.
Best Items to Order at Big Nita’s Cheesecakes 2026
Best first-time slice: Banana Pudding Cheesecake ($9.00) — Nicole Clark’s personal recommendation; the most popular single slice; described as tasting “like Memaw’s old-school banana pudding.”
Best premium slice: Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar ($10.00) — the bright, fruit-forward flavor that reviewers in the variety sampler consistently name as a standout.
Best for groups: Variety Sampler ($72.00) — the definitive Big Nita’s experience. One of every flavor, the ultimate tasting format for birthdays, events, or first-time visitors.
Best gift: Variety Cheesecake Cookie Box ($42.00) — 12 cheesecake-stuffed cookies across three flavors; the best value format for gifting.
Best single cookie: Snickerdoodle Cheesecake Filled Cookie ($4.00) — the most reviewed single cookie item in TikTok content.
Best seasonal: Whatever seasonal flavor is available that week — Caramel Apple (fall), Bailey’s Irish Cream Brownie (winter), Orange Dream (summer) are the most anticipated seasonal rotations.
Frequently Asked Questions — Big Nita’s Cheesecakes Menu 2026
Where is Big Nita’s Cheesecakes?
1011 E Main St, Butchertown, Louisville, KY 40206. Pickup from the side door.
What are Big Nita’s Cheesecakes hours?
Friday 1:00 PM–6:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM–2:00 PM, Sunday 11:00 AM–1:00 PM. Open three days per week; closed Monday–Thursday. She sells out early — arrive at least an hour before closing or pre-order online.
How do I order Big Nita’s Cheesecakes online?
Visit bignitascheesecakes.com. Pre-orders open Monday nights. Select your items, pick a pickup time slot, pay by card, pick up at the side door at 1011 E Main St.
Does Big Nita’s Cheesecakes ship?
No. Pickup only. No shipping. No delivery.
How much are Big Nita’s Cheesecakes?
Most slices are $9.00. Premium slices (Double Dot Cake, Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar) are $10.00. Cheesecake-stuffed cookies are $4.00 each. Variety Sampler is $72.00. Cookie Box is $42.00.
What is the most popular flavor at Big Nita’s?
Banana Pudding Cheesecake — Nicole Clark’s personal recommendation and the most consistently named must-try in all reviews.
What time does the line form at Big Nita’s?
Customers start lining up 1–2 hours before opening. Confirmed from Yelp Q&A. Pre-ordering online on Monday is the best way to guarantee your order.
What is the Big Nita’s Cheesecakes phone number?
(502) 883-0022
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes 2026 — Final Take
Big Nita’s Cheesecakes in 2026 is one of the most compelling small business stories in Louisville food — a food truck that outgrew itself, moved into a brick-and-mortar, and built a national TikTok reputation on the strength of genuinely exceptional cheesecake. The Banana Pudding is the soul of what Nicole Clark is doing. The Variety Sampler is the TikTok phenomenon. The Samoa Brownie Bottom and the Lemon Blueberry Crumble Bar are the ones you find yourself thinking about three days later.
The line is real. The sell-outs are real. The Monday pre-order is the insider move. And the people who drive 50 miles for this cheesecake aren’t wrong.
Address: 1011 E Main St, Butchertown, Louisville, KY 40206
Phone: (502) 883-0022
Website: bignitascheesecakes.com
Hours: Fri 1–6 PM | Sat 11AM–2PM | Sun 11AM–1PM (or until sold out)
Online ordering: bignitascheesecakes.com (pre-orders open Monday)
No shipping — pickup only
